Off payroll Government Review

Off payroll Government Review

As part of the government’s election campaign they pledged to review the upcoming changes to IR35. This was never likely to include a review over whether the legislation would be enacted, but simply whether it needed any further improvements.

The government have since undertook this review and published their findings. The report ( makes it absolutely clear that the legislation will come into effect in April 2020.

Soft approach to penalties

The report acknowledges that although large companies are well prepared, medium companies and contractors are less so. With this in mind, HMRC will take a soft approach to the legislation initially. That is to say, they will not issue penalties for the first 12 months whilst companies still get to grips with the new rules. Please note, this does not mean that liabilities will not be due, just that penalties will not be levied on top of those liabilities.

No campaigns on PSC’s

The report confirms again that HMRC will not use the change in legislation to target PSC’s where their IR35 status changes post April. This should provide some comfort to contractors.

When the rules apply from

Another question raised during the consultation process was when will the legislation apply from? The government have clarified this point and said that it relates to services provided after 6 April 2020 rather than it being based on any payments after this date, even if the services were provided before April.

Size of the client

There was some concern with the legislation that intermediaries in the supply chain may not be aware of the size of the client and so the government have said the legislation will include a provision which will require a client to respond to a request for information about their size.

Contracting out the work

One of the biggest areas of contention that we are seeing derives from trying to establish who is actually the client and whether the work has been outsourced to another business. HMRC have taken this on board and updated their Employment Status Manuals in this regard, see ESM 10000 for more information on this.

Offshore clients

The last notable point was clarification that where a client is wholly oversea’s with no UK presence, the old IR35 rules will apply and it will be the contractor who will be responsible for IR35 compliance.

HMRC lose again!
HMRC have suffered another defeat in their campaign in the media sector this time it was Canal Street Productions v HMRC. HMRC have been hugely unsuccessful in challenging companies under IR35 over the last decade and so when they started a new project, targeting the media sector and presenters, they...
Read More
2020 IR35 legislation
You can’t run from it, you can’t hide from it and despite some wishful thinking, IR35 will be changing from April 2020. April will come around before you know it and so it is better to get ahead of the curve and start considering how it may impact your business. What is changing? Everything, but also...
Read More
Off payroll Working book
Earlier in the year, Kye Burchmore was approached by Bloomsbury Publishing to see whether he would like to write a book about off-payroll working which would cover employment status, agency legislation, IR35 and the managed service company rules. Kye has previously worked with Bloomsbury when updating...
Read More